Battle of the Heavyweights

Posted on January 31, 2011, 03:01 PM by Jamie Kennedy
> Cool 21
|
> Poor 2

With StrikeForce's Heavyweight World Grand Prix Tournament just around the corner, I thought I could compare and contrast some of the best Heavyweight MMA fighters that currently reside in both the StrikeForce and the UFC's ranks. There has been a lot of debate surrounding the topic as of late, and hopefully I can shed some light on the current state of MMA's Heavyweights, and perhaps help to get a more definitive answer. 

First and foremost in many eyes StrikeForce's Heavyweight roster is arguably their best division, not only that but it is also a division with depth, and quite frankly StrikeForce is lacking in depth overall in their divisions, but one can not make that claim when talking about their Heavyweights. Many have criticised StrikeForce for being incapable of getting their Heavyweights in the cage, which is a fair criticism,  but their Heavyweight Grand Prix will surely put those claims to bed, with the eventual winner having a good case for being the Number. 1 heavyweight in the world, and possibly the Baddest Man on the Planet. 

I will give you a brief overview of the StrikeForce Heavyweight division, including their top fighters, credentials and most importantly their records. 

Strikeforce Heavyweights 

Champion: Alistair Overeem 

MMA Record : (W-L-D) 33-11-0 1,N.C

Age: 30 

Height: 6ft 5' 

Reach: 81.5' 

Strength: Kickboxing/Muay Thai 

Overeem holds the StrikeForce Heavyweight crown, and on top of that he won 2010's K1 World GP and ia also the DREAM heavyweight Champion, Now such credentials could easily stake a  claim for being the No.1 in the world, but Overeem's lack of actual MMA fighting this year has damaged this claim, and many have criticised him for not facing high level competition as he despatched of Todd Duffee and Brett Rogers. His K1 achievements are impressive, but sadly it's not MMA and you cant read to much into that. 

Fabricio Werdum 

MMA Record: 14-4-1 

Age: 33 

Height: 6ft 4'

Reach: 76' 

Strength: Brazilian Jiu Jitsu 

Werdum is coming off the biggest win of his career after he submitted the long undefeated Emperor; Fedor Emelianenko last year via triangle/armbar in the very first round. He will be brimming with confidence heading into the tournament and will face current Champ Overeem in a quarter final match-up, and strangely enough has a submission victory over Overeem when they fought in Japanese promotion PRIDE FC. Werdum is one of, if not the most accomplished submission specialists in MMA, and has won countless grappling tournaments, including the ADCC world championships on three occasions, and is a 2nd degree BJJ blackbelt. 

Fedor Emelianenko 

MMA Record: 32-2-1 

Age: 34 

Height: 6ft 0' 

Reach: 74' 

Strength: Sambo 

Fedor has had an illustrious career and was the long reigning Pound 4 Pound King of MMA before his sole loss to the aforementioned Werdum. Fedor is a former PRIDE FC heavyweight Champion and Grand Prix winner, and has beaten a who's who of MMA greats he has also competed in and won many MMA tournament format events, including RINGS & WAMMA, as far as experience in actual tournaments go I think Fedor will have a slight advantage over his counterparts.  Emelianenko has also represented his country in both Sambo and Judo world Championships and has been very successful in doing so; picking up many gold medals and top 3 places. Fedor is pitted against Brazilian giant Antonio Silva in his opening quarter final matchup that will feature in the tournament. 

Josh Barnett 

MMA Record: 26-5-0 

Age: 33

Height: 6ft 3' 

Reach: 76' 

Strength: Catch Wrestling/Submission Wrestling 

Barnett was successful early on in his MMA career and is a former UFC heavyweight Champion; although his title was later stripped from him as he tested positive for steroids and was cut by the UFC. Barnett a talented submission artist then took his talents to Japan and later won the King of Pancrase title, before fighting in PRIDE FC. Barnett had mixed success in PRIDE and made it to the Openweight Grand Prix Finals, losing out to Mirko Cro Cop. Barnett holds a blackbelt in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu but his style is more incorporated towards Catch Wrestling. Josh will face Brett Rogers in his quarter final match up as part of the StrikeForce tournament. 

Antonio Silva 

MMA Record: 15-2-0 

Age: 31 

Height: 6ft 4'

Reach: 82' 

Strength: Boxing/BJJ 

The Brazilian giant has competed in many MMA promotions throughout the years and was a Champion in the Elite XC promotion. Big Foot's most notable win to date is a unanimous decision victory over former UFC Champ Andrei Arlovski which happened last year at StrikeForce: Heavy Artillery. Silva holds a blackbelt in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, Judo as well as Karate and is an accomplished martial artist. Big Foot will be a heavy underdog going into his quarter final match up against Fedor, but one thing's for sure he shouldnt be taken lightly. 

Others in the mix: 

Andrei Arlovski, Sergei Kharitonov, Daniel Cormier, Shane Del Rosario, Brett Rogers, Valentijn Overeem, Bobby Lashley, Lavar Johnson

Now, the UFC's heavyweight division is very disputable, and arguably their weakest division with many believing Brock Lesnar being an unworthy title challenger never mind Champion and has since been dethroned at the hands of Cain Velasquez. Although the UFC have other fighters in their Heavyweight ranks there are very few outside of the top 5 of their division that are showing definite future contender status, and on top of that there not exactly brimming with young prospects either. Their Champ Velasquez is currently sidelined with a shoulder injury and it is unsure when he will return, leaving a perfect opportunity for the StrikeForce tournament winner to stake his claim for the Number one spot in the world, and with Lesnar and Dos Santos filming TUF there is little activity in this division recently. 

O.K here we go, down to business!! 

Champion: Cain Velasquez 

MMA Record 9-0-0

Age: 28

Height: 6ft 1' 

Reach: 77'

Strength: Wrestling 

Although Velasquez has only 9 professional fights he has bulldozed through everyone the UFC could throw at him, and despite his bread and butter being his wrestling he has only went the distance in one of his nine fights, his sole decision win coming against Cheick Kongo. Cain is undefeated and has despatched of MMA legend Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira via 1st rd KO en route to his title shot and utter destruction of Brock Lesnar; another 1st rd finish via TKO. Velasquez is still young in his MMA Career but has shown all the attributes of a champion, and has various college wrestling credentials to his name andis an All American state wrestling Champ.  Cain will square off against the winner of Brock Lesnar vs Junior Dos Santos in which will be his first UFC title defense.

Junior Dos Santos:  

MMA Record: 12-1-0 

Age: 26 

Height: 6ft 3'

Reach: 77' 

Strength: Boxing 

Dos Santos was originally set to take on Velasquez for the title, before the unexpected injury to the Champ, but will now instead take on Former Champ Brock Lesnar for number one contendership, while the Champ recovers. Junior will also coach on this seasons The Ultimate Fighter competition opposite Lesnar before the two square off. JDS is 6-0 inside the UFC's octagon and has finished five of his opponents via TKO or KO and has shown great potential and possesses alot of power and technique in his stand up game. JDS is a brown belt in BJJ under the tutelage of Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira and will have to get through Lesnar for his shot at glory. 

Brock Lesnar 

MMA Record: 5-2-0

Age: 33

Height: 6ft 3' 

Reach: 81'

Strength: Wrestling 

Despite having only 7 professional MMA fights, Lesnar has accomplished a lot in the short span that has been his MMA career. He has beaten two former world Champions in Frank Mir and the legendary Randy Couture. And has a submission victory over the heavy hittin' Shane Carwin. Lesnar was famously hailed as the ''Baddest Man on the Planet'' but after Cain Velasquez made him look anything but what his moniker suggested, Lesnar has licked his wounds and is ready to make a comeback, and will take on the aforementioned Dos Santos in a bid to get one step closer to regaining his championship. Lesnar is also an NCAA Division l wrestling Champ and had a successful run throughout his college career. 

Shane Carwin 

MMA Record: 12-1-0 

Age: 36 

Height: 6ft 2' 

Reach: 80' 

Strength: Boxing 

Carwin is 4-1 in the UFC with all 4 of his wins coming by way of KO/TKO and definitely packs dynamite in his fists. His only loss came to former Champ Brock Lesnar via arm triangle, after Carwin had effectively punched himself out in the first round when he put a hurting on the Champ, Brock survived to come back and clinch the win in the 2nd. Shane also has win over former champ Frank Mir, he TKO'd Mir in the first round to secure his shot at Lesnar and also the Interim UFC Heavyweight Championship. On top of his impressive punching power, Carwin is also a NCAA Division ll wrestling Champion and even has a numberofwins via submission. Carwin's next opponent is still unknown, but he is back in training after a lengthly lay off due to a back injury. 

Frank Mir 

MMA Record: 14-5-0 

Age: 31

Height: 6ft 3' 

Reach: 79 

Strength: Brazilian Jiu Jitsu 

Mir is a former 2 time UFC heavyweight Champion and is arguably the best submission artist the UFC Heavyweight Divisionhas to offer and has seven submission victories in the UFC's octagon, Mir has never been submitted and holds a black belt in Brazilian Jiu Jitsu under BJJ great Robert Drysdale. Mir has a submission victory over former Champ Brock Lesnar, but that loss was later avenged by Brock. Frank has been hot and cold lately after losing to Lesnar, he went onto defeat Cheick Kongo before losing out to Shane Carwin, and in his most recent UFC outing he KO'd MMA Legend Mirko Cro Cop. Mir is slated to face Roy Nelson at UFC 130 and will need a win if he is make another run at the title. 

Others in the mix: Antonio Rodrigo Nogueira, Mirko Cro Cop, Brendan Schaub, Stefan Struve, Travis Browne, Cheick Kongo, Ben Rothwell, Roy Nelson 

O.K folks that's the wrap and the only thing left to do is decide. Now, my aim was for people to vote based on an overall perspective of who has the best division; deeper talent pool, better combatants. and not to be based upon whether you think one fighter would beat another fighter from a different promotion. 

Like always here on LowKick.com we let you guys, the fans decide. Make your choice, and choose wisely LowKickers! 

  1. 1. UFC Heavyweights
  2. 2. Strikeforce Heavyweights

Comments

REGISTER OR LOG IN TO POST COMMENTS AND BECOME AN ACTIVE MEMBER OF THE COMMUNITY
  • evilways
    Funny
    40
    Weak | 3
    Sharp | 1
    Cool | 0

    I say strikeforce, but Dana told me i'm wrong

    Reply 2 years ago
  • Scrappler
    Sharp
    14
    Weak | 3
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    Dana is very good at convincing people that the UFC is the best and that all the other organizations suck. It's one of his talents..

    Reply 2 years ago
  • Ninja
    Sharp
    9
    Weak | 1
    Cool | 1
    Funny | 0

    It's hard to say which is better....overall I hve more UFC HW's in my top 10 list however I hve 3 SF HW's in my top 5 so its a hard call to make

    Reply 2 years ago
  • garry_blackbelt
    Sharp
    6
    Weak | 2
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    lol! strike force by far ! has better heavy weights than ufc ! dana is just going too hate that when every 1 eles finds out the truth! shame on you dana calling cokers strike force a side show!

    Reply 2 years ago
  • dattebayou
    Sharp
    1
    Weak | 1
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    lol. i'd say the the strikeforce HW has more MMA exprerience than their UFC Counterparts. well except for frank mir.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • kinosis79
    Sharp
    2
    Weak | 2
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    The ufc may have more HWs but they are guys who don't matter and will never even be in the top 30.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • TheMMAfan
    Cool
    Weak
    Sharp
    Funny

    I hear you bro, overeem and fedor top 2 but ufc has the rest. Very difficult to pick

    Reply 2 years ago
  • Ninja
    Sharp
    2
    Weak | 1
    Cool | 1
    Funny | 0

    @edub



    My top 5 r

    Cain

    Overeem

    Dos Santos

    Werdum

    Fedor

    Reply 2 years ago
  • TenderRainDrop
    Sharp
    5
    Weak | 2
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    Even if the tournament falls through (fingers crossed) Strikeforce still has the majority of HWs that are more accomplished then the UFC HW's. Fedor alone has accomplished more then the UFC's HW's.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • overhand right
    Sharp
    13
    Weak | 2
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    Overeem and Fedor alone make Strikeforce's Heavyweight division better.



    The HW Gran Prix is going to be the best thing happening in MMA in 2011!

    Reply 2 years ago
  • overhand right
    Sharp
    5
    Weak | 2
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    and he's had more fights than most ufc heavyweights combined and has proven he's 10x the fighter of the guys he's fought recently. don't honestly tell me he wouldn't cream half the ufc roster.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • overhand right
    Cool
    Weak
    Sharp
    Funny

    stop gibbering on with rankings already, they're completely subjective, biased and in reality really show nothing about a fighter's skill or potential. you can't put a number on what could or could not happen in a fight. most rankings (especially on here) are just a popularity contest.



    and why would overeem need to fight in the ufc when the most talented heavyweights are fighting over at strikeforce? what is going over there and tko'ing brock in the first round like cain did going to prove about reem that we don't already know? he'll be fighting more regularly and against better opposition in 2011 than any ufc hw.



    yeah he hasn't fought any great wrestelers at heavyweight. just like cain hasn't fought any great strikers or jds hasn't fought any wrestlers or blah blah blah. you can use that excuse for any fighter. the facts are that overeem has done the best he can against the opposition he's been provided with and proved his greatness when he dismantled rogers, a guy who gave fedor the hardest fight he'd had in a long time.



    you either think overeem is a great fighter or you don't, most reasonable fans do. if you actually think jon madsen would give him trouble then you're out of your mind.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • p4pfedor
    Sharp
    4
    Weak | 1
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    Why he is a SF HW.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • AnAmerican
    Sharp
    1
    Funny | 0
    Weak | 0
    Cool | 0

    interesting to note that everyone on this list is in their 30's except for Cain and Dos Santos.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • xdecemberguy
    Weak
    7
    Funny | 2
    Sharp | 0
    Cool | 0

    No Brainer..UFC has the best HW. Better records. Most are younger. Fight more top fighters. Everyone is going to say, but wait..What about Gaydor. I'm sorry he hasn't fought any really good challenges in a very long time. Joined Strikeforce and almost got his face smashed in. Next fight caught by an armbar, and the sad thing is he knew he was going for it and still took the bait. UFC..Look at the names. Carwin, Cain, Brock. Strikeforces rating on T.V. are a joke. People know who have the best fighters and the rating show that. Done.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • TenderRainDrop
    Sharp
    3
    Weak | 1
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    Not to be a prick but i think you just described yourself as a Zuffa Zombie, just by saying "Look at the names..." & and "ratings" my head hurts for you. You cannot be serious...can you?

    Reply 2 years ago
  • Tchelnik
    Sharp
    1
    Weak | 1
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    are u 12?

    Reply 2 years ago
  • PassDaLiqqahNiqqah
    Weak
    6
    Funny | 0
    Sharp | 0
    Cool | 0

    Andrei Arlovski lost all three of his last fights(TKO,KO and Decision)

    Brett Rogers got KO'ed,TKO'ed,and won his last fight by beating a guy with a

    19-18 record

    Josh Bannet is a scumbag steriod abuser 3x champion discrace

    And to be honest I didnt know who Sergei Kharitonov was untill like a week ago

    Reply 2 years ago
  • TenderRainDrop
    Sharp
    4
    Funny | 0
    Weak | 0
    Cool | 0

    It's not Sergei's fault you don't know who he is.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • p4pfedor
    Funny
    2
    Sharp | 1
    Weak | 0
    Cool | 0

    Pointless fact : In the top HW's in each company, Strikeforce has the fighters with the longest and shortest reach.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • mokoko
    Sharp
    2
    Weak | 1
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    UFC never had the best HW's most of UFC top HW were Dana's self made top 10 fighters with no top 10 fights.Any one in Sf HW devision can beat Lesnar ewen Lashley

    Reply 2 years ago
  • Rafael_Roberto
    Sharp
    2
    Weak | 1
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    You gotta remember lots of Strikeforce's best heavyweights were originally from the UFC. So I gotta go with the UFC.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • GILLEStheBRAVE
    Sharp
    1
    Weak | 1
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    Like Fedor and Overeem. looooool

    Reply 2 years ago
  • Rafael_Roberto
    Sharp
    2
    Funny | 0
    Weak | 0
    Cool | 0

    I meant Arlovski, Barnett, and Werdum.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • GILLEStheBRAVE
    Cool
    1
    Funny | 0
    Weak | 0
    Sharp | 0

    I know what you're thinking

    -I'm just joking :):)

    Reply 2 years ago
  • Rafael_Roberto
    Cool
    Weak
    Sharp
    Funny

    Fedor and Overeem got famous in Pride

    Reply 2 years ago
  • brookstar
    Weak
    2
    Funny | 0
    Sharp | 0
    Cool | 0

    This shouldnt even really be close strike forces 6 top heavyweights are not as good as the ufc's. brett rogers biggest win was over a guy won was cut from the ufc and he almost took out Fedor who was for sure the best heavyweight ever but wouldnt fight the best in the ufc and just lost to another guy who was knocked out by a guy new ufc rookie (at the time). josh barnett has proven he is a life time juicer so he will never get a chance to fight the ufc guys and as much as i like watching overeem i cant see him be able to deal with the wreslting of brock or cain. im a couple of the guys in strikeforce couldnt beat anyone in the ufc but as for the stronger division ufc hands down. I know this is going to get weaked alot so bring it on nubs

    Reply 2 years ago
  • CageRage64
    Cool
    Weak
    Sharp
    Funny

    P4P rankings are questionable and specualative at best. It's like asking ten people who they think the best fighter in the world is, and getting ten different "opinions" back. There will always be a handful of fighters that one can argue is the "best" P4P. P4P is meaningless in the big picture of a fighter's career, and there will never be a definitive P4P fighter.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • xdecemberguy
    Weak
    2
    Sharp | 1
    Funny | 0
    Cool | 0

    Ok outside source. UFC still has more Top-Ten HW. Sherdog http://www.sherdog.com/news/articles/2/Sherdog-Official-Mixed-Martial-Arts-Rankings-28893

    All you haters on the UFC...When your on TOP every takes a swipe at you.

    Reply 2 years ago
  • TenderRainDrop
    Sharp
    1
    Funny | 0
    Weak | 0
    Cool | 0

    Okay, Strikeforce HW's have the deeper resumes then UFC's HW's. Just based on experience, the top dogs are in SF. Just because they have the brand of the biggest MMA company (UFC) does not automatically make them better then SF. The heavyweights of UFC are unproven. They have potential but thats about it.

    Reply 2 years ago